Park maintance men cleaning up the park getting ready to plant flowers found a knife and turned it over to the police.That knife was exactly the same as what they had in their possession. This one had blood all over it but no finger prints. The lab confirmed it was Allison's blood. Now they had two knives. Detective Reagan thought to himself this is getting weirder as the case moves forward and those poor babies have been missing for almost a week.
The lead investigator that was in charge over all of the detectives change the status of the missing children to probable homicide victims by now. Since Jack could not afford his bail money they grilled him again with this time detective O'Brien doing the grilling. Again Jack claimed his innocence. He would look detective Reagan face to face and begged him to find the babies. He was on the brink of a full mental break down. he was put on suicide watch.
Detective Reagan received a call from the pub's manager in Roscarbery about the tape that Jack's father asked him to find. Detective Reagan drove those two hours after work in the middle of the night to retrieve the tape. Clearly on the tape it showed Jack sitting with the young lady. He told the manager that Jack said he had never sat with a lady at the pub.
While watching the tape further it clearly showed the young woman going back and forth from the little table Jack was sitting to a longer table that other people were sitting at. The manager told him exactly what he had told Jack's father. Detective Reagan asked him if this young lady could be Jack's mistress and accomplice. The manager looked right in the eye and replied Heavens no that's my daughter who still lives at home with my wife and I. Detective Reagan took the tape back to Walshbury.
The next day while driving past the park there were several policemen and women plus four dogs searching the park for the children's bodies. Detective Reagan talked to Melissa alone. He told her that Jack could not have put the last letter in her mail box because he was still in jail. She said well his mistress did and she has my babies. Detective Reagan put the tape in her DVD player. She didn't want to watch him with his mistress. Detective said please Jack really didn't do anything wrong. She sat quietly watching the whole tape and realized what a fool she had been.
While driving back to the station they past the park and she started crying and said if only I had listen to Jack I might have saved our babies. Their deaths are on me and not Jack. When they reached the jail. Jack wasn't allowed out of his cell. they preceded down to his cell. When jack saw Melissa he quickly jumped up and went to the cell bars and told her using his nickname for her Mel I didn't do anything to our precious babies. I don't know anything about these letters or anything. I would give my life to be able to bring our babies back to you.